Torah Lens · A headline. A source. A moment inward.Israel · America · The Jewish world
TorahLens← The daily edition

The insult wanted the next sentence. Who chose its tone?

The question

When anger has a real grievance behind it, do I let the offender decide the tone that comes out of my own mouth?

Learn the source

In Shaar HaKeniah, Rabbeinu Bachya lists signs through which inner humility becomes visible: הלשון הרכה והקול הנמוך והענוה בעת הכעס—‘Gentle speech, a lowered voice, and humility at a time of anger.’

The test is not the quiet moment when nothing presses against the self. He places the softer tongue and lowered voice precisely בעת הכעס—when anger has already arrived and retaliation feels available.

The next chapter distinguishes genuine humility from helplessness or failure to defend oneself. A lowered voice is therefore not consent to abuse. It is the choice not to let anger take authorship of one's conduct before Hashem.

Chovos Halevavos · Shaar HaKeniah, chapter 1 ↗

The news in brief

What happened

JNS reported on November 19 that two days earlier Gabe Einhorn, visibly Jewish and wearing a kippah, was making street interviews in Manhattan's Washington Square Park when a young man approached and rapped about gas chambers while laughing.

A video Einhorn posted and JNS reviewed shows him responding, ‘You think you're funny, bro?’; a second young man then appeared embarrassed and apologized.

Einhorn told JNS that threats after an earlier antisemitic incident led him to hire security and remain alert while filming.

He also described giving food to homeless people with a Muslim participant and said his public aim was to do something good and spread peace and love.

JNS · Jewish entrepreneur responds to an antisemitic taunt in Washington Square Park · 19 November 2026 ↗

Torah Lens · our application

Return to the news

The moment did not become harmless because Einhorn did not answer with a matching insult. A Holocaust taunt aimed at a visible Jew is hate, and Chovos Halevavos is not asking the targeted person to accept danger or surrender protection. The inward question begins with us, in safer and smaller moments: what happens to the size of my own voice when anger has given me a real grievance? A lowered voice is not passivity. It keeps the wrongdoer from choosing the form of my response. Einhorn's next public emphasis—doing good with people of another faith—does not erase the insult; it shows a direction not dictated by it. Before Hashem, restraint can mean that anger supplies information and energy, while humility still chooses the words.

Stay with the thought

First, keep the moral fact clear. A Holocaust taunt directed at a visibly Jewish person is not harmless because the response remained controlled. The wrong belongs to the person who chose the taunt, and nobody targeted by hate owes strangers a performance of serenity.

Einhorn's response is still worth noticing as a courageous human choice. He challenged what happened without answering in the language offered to him. His security precautions also matter: softness in speech did not mean pretending that threats were safe.

Rabbeinu Bachya's vaad begins when the incident turns toward my own conduct. Anger may be justified and still try to enlarge my voice, sharpen an unnecessary word, or make the other person's ugliness the model for my reply. A lowered voice does not erase the grievance. It keeps possession of the response.

The later choice to make constructive content across faiths does not explain why the encounter happened and does not certify anyone's merit. It shows a direction that the insult did not get to choose. In the smaller anger of a kitchen, office, car or phone call, avodah can begin with one question: will this grievance provide information, or will it be allowed to write my next sentence?

Chovos Halevavos · Shaar HaKeniah, chapter 1 ↗JNS · Jewish entrepreneur responds to an antisemitic taunt in Washington Square Park · 19 November 2026 ↗

A small step, if you choose

Take one thing with you

In one safe moment of anger today, lower your volume by one notch before answering. Keep the truth of the grievance; choose the form of the words yourself.

A reflection, not a personal halachic ruling.
Sources & reporting notes 2 references
  1. JNS · Jewish entrepreneur responds to an antisemitic taunt in Washington Square Park · 19 November 2026 ↗

    Date-only report retrieved November 20. JNS interviewed Gabe Einhorn and reviewed the video he posted. It documents the taunt, his brief response, the second young man's apology, the security precautions Einhorn described and his stated choice to make constructive interfaith content. The report links the primary video; no identity or motive is assigned to the young men beyond what is visible and reported.

  2. Chovos Halevavos · Shaar HaKeniah, chapter 1 ↗

    Exact approved automatic-corpus excerpt and Torah Lens's original English rendering. The chapter lists outward signs of inward humility, including restraint when anger rises. The next chapter distinguishes humility from helplessness or inability to defend oneself. The application is limited to voluntary restraint in the reader's own safe moments; it does not ask a victim to tolerate abuse or abandon protection.

Hebrew passages are quoted sources; English renderings are our own. The event connection and suggested reflection are Torah Lens’s application. Prepared with AI assistance. Rabbinic supervision has not yet been established.