They entered the beis midrash before asking to be understood. Who makes the first move?
Do I wait for someone unfamiliar to understand my world before I take the first respectful step into theirs?
Learn the source
After Abaye teaches about increasing peace with every person, Berachos records this about Rabban Yochanan ben Zakkai: שלא הקדימו אדם שלום מעולם ואפילו נכרי בשוק—“No person ever greeted him first, even a non-Jew in the marketplace.”
The point is not merely that he answered politely. Nobody greeted him first because he did not make human regard wait for the other person’s initiative. Even the unfamiliar person in the market was not placed outside that practice.
A greeting is not agreement, trust without judgment or the erasure of danger. It is a first act of derech eretz: recognizing the person before reciprocity has begun.
What happened
On November 16, a group of 11 Catholic clergy and officials from France, Germany and Rwanda visited Yeshiva University’s Washington Heights campus in Manhattan.
JNS reported that the visitors toured the beis midrash, where one French priest said the volume of Torah study surprised him on his first visit to a yeshiva.
Yeshiva University president Rabbi Ari Berman said such visits create opportunities to discuss shared challenges and possibilities.
Participants discussed religious education, artificial intelligence, end-of-life questions and cooperation; JNS said antisemitism was addressed but was not the meeting’s main focus.
JNS · Catholic clergy visit Yeshiva University in Manhattan · 16 November 2026 ↗Archdiocese of Reims · Archbishop Éric de Moulins-Beaufort’s November 2026 agenda · 9 November 2026 ↗
Return to the news
The delegation did not learn a beis midrash by description alone; its members entered the room, heard the kol Torah and spoke with the people who live there. That does not erase theological differences, certify every statement made at the meeting or guarantee friendship. It does reveal the moral importance of initiative. Rabban Yochanan ben Zakkai’s greeting did not wait for the unfamiliar person to prove warmth first. In ordinary avodah, we often demand understanding before offering regard: “Let them ask me; let them greet me; let them show good faith.” The Gemara reverses the order. Where an encounter is safe, a sincere hello can recognize the tzelem Elokim before agreement arrives.
Stay with the thought
The striking detail is not a declaration issued from a distance. Visitors entered an actual beis midrash and encountered Torah learning as sound, argument, movement and people. One priest’s surprise at the noise shows how much an unfamiliar room can resist our prior picture of it.
A visit does not resolve theology, erase history or guarantee that every sentence spoken there was right. It is not proof that antisemitism has disappeared. The event offers a narrower mashal: understanding often begins after someone chooses not to wait outside.
Rabban Yochanan ben Zakkai’s greeting moved first. In our ordinary encounters, pride and caution can borrow each other’s language: let the neighbor greet me, let the coworker explain, let the newcomer show interest. Sometimes safety truly requires distance. But often we are simply making respect contingent on reciprocity.
Where an encounter is safe, the first hello, invitation or honest question does not surrender conviction. It recognizes tzelem Elokim before agreement is complete. That small initiative can let the other person become a person rather than the version of a category we had carried in our head.
Berachos 17a · Rabban Yochanan ben Zakkai ↗JNS · Catholic clergy visit Yeshiva University in Manhattan · 16 November 2026 ↗Archdiocese of Reims · Archbishop Éric de Moulins-Beaufort’s November 2026 agenda · 9 November 2026 ↗
Take one thing with you
In one safe encounter today, greet or ask first. Let respectful curiosity arrive before the demand that the other person understand you.
A reflection, not a personal halachic ruling.Sources & reporting notes 3 references
- JNS · Catholic clergy visit Yeshiva University in Manhattan · 16 November 2026 ↗
Date-only first-hand report retrieved November 18. JNS interviewed visitors and Yeshiva University leaders and photographed the gathering. Torah Lens links and summarizes the report without republishing it; no publication time is inferred.
- Archdiocese of Reims · Archbishop Éric de Moulins-Beaufort’s November 2026 agenda · 9 November 2026 ↗
Primary institutional agenda retrieved November 18. It independently lists a Yeshiva University program in New York from November 15 through 19. It confirms the scheduled visit but not the detailed remarks reported by JNS.
- Berachos 17a · Rabban Yochanan ben Zakkai ↗
Exact approved automatic-corpus excerpt and Torah Lens’s original English rendering. Following Abaye’s teaching about increasing peace with every person, the Gemara records that Rabban Yochanan ben Zakkai greeted others first, including a non-Jew in the marketplace. The application asks only about the reader’s own safe initiative; it does not erase disagreement, infer anyone’s motives or create a new halachic obligation.
Hebrew passages are quoted sources; English renderings are our own. The event connection and suggested reflection are Torah Lens’s application. Prepared with AI assistance. Rabbinic supervision has not yet been established.